The Biggest Refereeing Mistakes in the History of Football and Their Impacts

8 months back Diego 7 minutes reading time

Between controversial moves and controversial decisions, the biggest refereeing mistakes marked the history of the sport, generating consequences that go beyond the results of the matches.

The Importance of Refereeing in Football

The role of the referee is essential to ensure impartiality and compliance with the rules.

However, human errors are inevitable, and some of them have become true chapters in the history of the sport.

According to a study by the University of Liverpool, around 20% of controversial decisions in high-level games directly influence the final result.

The Phantom Goal of 1966

One of the most iconic moments occurred in the 1966 World Cup final between England and West Germany.

Geoff Hurst, an English player, kicked the ball against the post, and it bounced close to the goal line.

The referee allowed the goal, even without technology to confirm whether the ball had actually crossed the line.

This error is considered one of the biggest refereeing mistakes in history and helped England win its only world title.

The move sparked debates about the need for technology in football, culminating in the introduction of VAR (Video Assistant Referee) decades later.

The discussion about the implementation of technology continues to be a hot topic in football, with many fans and experts calling for more innovations.

+ Women's Football: Overcoming and Achievements

Maradona's Hand of God

In 1986, Diego Maradona scored a goal with his hand against England in the World Cup quarter-finals.

The referee didn't see the illegal touch and allowed the goal, which became known as “The Hand of God”.

This mistake not only eliminated England but also cemented Maradona as a sporting legend.

The case reinforced the discussion about ethics in football and the importance of transparency in refereeing decisions.

After this incident, many began to question the integrity of decisions in high-pressure games.

Maradona's figure became even more controversial, with this goal being a milestone in his career, but also a symbol of ethical debate.

The Penalty Not Awarded to Brazil in 1978

In the 1978 World Cup, Brazil faced Sweden in a crucial match.

Zico was clearly fouled inside the box, but the referee didn't award a penalty.

The game ended in a draw, and Brazil was eliminated in the next phase.

This is one of the biggest refereeing mistakes which still generates outrage among Brazilian fans.

The controversy increased pressure for changes to the rules and referee training, aiming for greater precision in decisions.

This episode also led to an increase in public outcry for a review system that could correct these errors in real time.

Zidane's Unfair Expulsion in 2006

In the 2006 World Cup final, Zinédine Zidane was sent off after headbutting Marco Materazzi.

The referee didn't see the verbal provocations that led to Zidane's reaction, and the sending off changed the course of the match.

Italy won on penalties, and Zidane ended his career on a sad note.

The case raised questions about player psychology and the need for referees to better understand the context of actions on the field.

Zidane's expulsion sparked debate about the need for a system that could take players' behavior into account before making decisions.

Furthermore, many have argued that referees should be better trained to deal with high-tension and provocative situations.

Liverpool's Disallowed Goal in 2005

In the 2005 Champions League, Liverpool had a legitimate goal disallowed against Chelsea.

The error prevented the team from advancing in the competition and generated widespread protests.

This incident was one of the catalysts for the adoption of VAR in high-level competitions, aiming to avoid similar errors in the future.

Fans and players cried out for justice, and pressure mounted on football authorities to make changes.

Furthermore, the disallowance of the goal raised questions about the need for more transparency in refereeing decisions.

The lack of clarity in some decisions continues to be a challenge to the credibility of the competitions.

The Non-existent Foul in Barcelona x Chelsea (2009)

In the 2009 Champions League semi-finals, the referee failed to award several clear fouls to Barcelona against Chelsea.

In the end, the Spanish team scored a goal in stoppage time and eliminated Chelsea.

The game is often cited as an example of how biggest refereeing mistakes can benefit specific teams, generating conspiracy theories and distrust in football institutions.

This incident not only damaged Chelsea's morale, but also raised questions about the impartiality of refereeing in decisive matches.

Furthermore, the resulting controversy has led to increased scrutiny of refereeing decisions in high-profile matches.

This type of situation can undermine the trust of fans and clubs in the institutions that govern football.

VAR and the Future of Arbitration

The introduction of VAR in 2018 brought significant advances, but also new challenges.

Although technology has reduced the occurrence of serious errors, critics argue that it interferes with the pace of the game and the excitement of football.

VAR represents a balance between accuracy and tradition, but there is still room for improvement.

Fans often feel frustrated by interruptions and lack of clarity in decisions.

Furthermore, the implementation of VAR has not completely eliminated controversies, as there are still debates about how and when it should be used.

The evolution of refereeing continues to be a central theme in discussions about the future of football.

Conclusion

You biggest refereeing mistakes in football history are not just moments of injustice; they are catalysts for change.

Each mistake sparked debates, reforms, and technological advances that shaped the sport we know today.

As football continues to evolve, the pursuit of fairness and accuracy will remain a priority.

For more information on the evolution of refereeing in football, visit FIFA – The History of Refereeing.

Table 1: Main Arbitration Errors and Their Impacts

Year	Game	Error	Impact
1966	England vs Germany	Phantom goal	Introduction of technology
1986	Argentina vs England	Hand of God	Debate on ethics
1978	Brazil vs Sweden	Penalty not awarded	Pressure for rule changes
2006	France vs Italy	Zidane's expulsion	Discussion on psychology
2005	Liverpool vs Chelsea	Goal disallowed	VAR Adoption
2009	Barcelona vs Chelsea	Unmarked fouls	Distrust in institutions

Table 2: Statistics on Refereeing Errors

Error Type	Frequency (%)	Consequence
Invalid goal	15	Elimination in competitions
Penalty not awarded	20	Loss of titles
Unfair expulsion	10	Change in the course of the game
Foul not called	25	Undue advantage

This data reinforces the importance of continuing to invest in technology and training to minimize errors and ensure the integrity of football.

Soccer